WIT Press


Estimating Slope From Raster Data: A Test Of Eight Different Algorithms In Flat, Undulating And Steep Terrain

Price

Free (open access)

Paper DOI

10.2495/RM110131

Volume

146

Pages

12

Page Range

143 - 154

Published

2011

Size

696 kb

Author(s)

J. Tang & P. Pilesjö

Abstract

Eight frequently used slope algorithms based on a DEM (Digital Elevation Model) have been compared in flat, gently sloping/undulating, and steep terrain in order to investigate differences in estimated results. The matter of scale/resolution has not been considered, and the focus has not been on comparing the estimates with \“ground truth” data but on comparisons between the different algorithms. Pair-wise statistical tests have been carried out to detect significant differences between the methods in general, and also between different terrains. In this way, we make explanations and recommendations regarding these differences and \“best practice” depending on data/terrain. Keywords: DEM, slope, algorithm, terrain. 1 Introduction The estimation of slope from a regularly-gridded DEM is a common procedure in terrain analysis. Some authors have evaluated the accuracy of various slope algorithms, using different assessment methodologies. The results of the slope estimations are always dependent on the generalization/resolution and quality of the DEM. Even though a number of studies, based on different types of \“ground truth” data, have been presented, there are no reports with the aim to investigate possible differences between different slope algorithms and their sensitivity in different terrain. In this paper, eight frequently used slope algorithms are evaluated against each other. They are applied in three different terrain forms, namely flat, gently sloping/undulating, and steep terrain. The estimated slope

Keywords

DEM, slope, algorithm, terrain